
McHenry Accident Reconstruction 2000
by Raymond R. McHenry & Brian G. McHenry
Contents
Index of Tables vii
List of Figures viii
Introduction & General Topics 1
Introduction 1
Terminology 2
Closing speed 2
Impact Speed Change (V) 2
Barrier Equivalent Velocity (BEV) 3
Coefficient of Restitution 4
Cornering Stiffness And Static Margin 5
Cornering Stiffness 5
Static Margin 7
Sample Application 8
Limitations on the Ability of a Vehicle to Change its Direction of Motion 9
Collinear Central Collisions 16
Collinear Central Collisions (cont.) 17
Error Analysis 17
References 18
Vehicle Control Factors 19
Introduction 19
Wet Pavement 19
Hydroplaning 19
Shoulder Excursions, Pavement Edges 23
References 23
Trajectory Analysis 25
Introduction 25
Linear Motions Without Yawing 25
Spinouts on Flat, Uniform Surfaces 27
Combined Rotation and Translation Subsequent to Collision 31
Yaw Inertia 33
Sample Applications 34
Further Reading 34
Conservation of Momentum 37
Sample Application 1 41
Sample Application 2 - Intersection Collision 44
Sample Application 3 47
References 48
Damage Analysis 49
Introduction 49
History and Analytical Basis 49
Impulse-Energy Relationship 58
Side Impacts: 58
NHTSA Research 61
Forced Intercepts 61
Custom-Fitted Coefficients 64
Abandonment of A, B and G 64
Comparison of Crush Property Definitions 66
Energy Correction Factor and Coefficient of Restitution 67
Energy Correction Factor 67
Coefficient of Restitution 70
2000 Update 70
OFFSET FRONTAL COLLISIONS 75
Refinement in the Simulation of Structural Interactions During Collisions 80
Snag Option 81
References 83
Crush Coefficients 85
Crush Coefficients Derived from Crash Test Data 85
Sample Application to Moving Barrier (Rigid) Test Data: 87
Prasad Coefficients, d0, d1 90
Compatible Crush Definitions for the CRASH and SMAC Computer Programs 91
Sample Calculation 92
References 94
Occupant Trajectory 95
Distance Traveled by an Ejected Vehicle Occupant or Component 95
Simple Ballistic Trajectory 95
Ballistic Trajectory Followed by Sliding 97
Simple Horizontal Launch 98
Horizontal Launch Followed by Sliding 99
LAUNCH Routine. 101
Pole/Tree Collisions 103
Introduction 103
Work-Energy Relationships 103
Conservation of Angular Momentum 105
Relationships for Pure Rotation about Tree/Pole 107
Sample Applications 107
Pole Impact Damage Analysis 110
Sample Application: 111
Crush Properties for m-smac Pole Impacts 117
Effects of Vehicle Pitch 119
References 120
Rollovers 121
Introduction 121
Resistance to Rollover 121
“Static Stability” Factor 121
Tripping Type Rollovers 122
Non-Tripping Type Rollovers 122
Literature Review 122
Minimum Lateral Speed for a Tripping-Type Rollover 124
Speed Required for a Lateral Rollover Beyond 90 126
End-Over-End Rollover 128
References 129
Speed Change at Occupant Positions 130
Background 130
Full-Scale Test Results 131
Test Equivalent Speed Change 132
SMAC Equivalent Speed Change 132
Demonstration of Positional Differences in Speed-Change 133
CG-Transform Procedure 135
References 138
CRASH Damage Analysis 139
Introduction 139
References 140
CRASH Trajectory Solution Procedure 141
Introduction 141
Discussion 145
Tire-to-ground “External” Forces 147
Impact Duration 148
SMAC Computer Program 151
Introduction 151
Current Status of SMAC 152
References 153
HVOSM & 3D Reconstruction Analysis 157
Introduction 157
Research Rationale for Computer Simulation Models 157
HVOSM - Highway Vehicle Object Simulation Model 158
Analytical Approach of the HVOSM 158
The Astro-Spiral Jump 161
Research with HVOSM 162
References 174
CVS/ATB Occupant Simulation Model 177
Introduction 177
Appendix 1 179
Forms of Restitution Behavior 179
Appendix 2 181
Conversion Factors 181
ERRATA 187
Changes made to document since Nov 2000 187
Index 189